This is my favorite pizza place in Madison. I live on the west side and will routinely drive all the way down to state street just to pick up a pie here for carry out . Yes, the restaurant isn't spotless and could use a remodel, but the classic New York style pizza (big, floppy slices) makes up for it.
I almost always order carry out so I don't have to worry about getting an old slice that's been sitting out forever, but the slices taste reasonably good even when they're re-oven'ed. Never had a major problem even microwaving a slice for lunch the next day.