I went to Gibby's for my birthday a few years ago and loved it. They made it so special for me and my friends. So I went back recently with my husband, had the same thing as the first time (beef Wellington) and it was so awful. The Monte Carlo potato was amazing and thank god it was because it's all I could eat on that plate. Even the starter salad was disgusting, tasted like old leftovers from a dorm room fridge. This place is supposed to be legendary and for the price it should be every.single.meal. Never will I go back to this dated cave with bad beef.