Overpriced and overrated.
I've been looking forward to trying Those Guys because of all these good reviews. I had a "buy 1, get 1" coupon so I figured that was a bonus!
The shop is small and hidden and the employees were friendly enough, but the pizza did not live up to the 4 stars it gets here on yelp. We ordered 2 pies: the "Shroom" and the "Spicy Red Italian". They were ready in about 20 minutes.
I always make sure I try a slice before I get home because a 15-20 minute drive can do terrible things to a pizza and I want an honest "out of the oven" opinion. We found a spot outside and opened the boxes only to find two very wet looking pies. I tried picking up a slice and it was so limp I basically ended up with a handful of toppings and grease. I had to fold it in half and even then, the tip had to be folded up into the middle of the slice. I ended up sucking out the ingredients like pizza soup.
Taste-wise, it wasn't too bad and the ingredients seemed fresh but the crust could not stand up to them. It was a very messy situation. If I hadn't had the 2 for 1 coupon I would have been really upset as those two pies would have run me about $45. Seriously? I've worked in a pizza shop before so I know pizza doesn't have to cost that much.
I seem to be in the minority here but I definitely won't be rushing back to Those Guys any time soon. There are much better options out there.