Places with really small menus have to be very good at what they do in order to make it... and Dewey's nails it.
The menu here is quite barren... a couple salads, calzones and pizzas. Nothing else. Fortunately, the pizza is spectacular. The secret is clearly out, as during dinner the line can be rather significant.
The wife and I shared a large pizza with tomato, onion and basil... The pizza was bigger than I thought that it would be, which is good because nothing.. NOTHING beats left over pizza. The pizza was almost perfect... it could have stood maybe another minute in the oven to crisp up the crust a tiny bit more, but that is just nit picking. It was the best I've had so far in Cleveland. The service is also quite friendly. The place was packed, yet my drink was always refilled before empty. That is how it should be done.
One minor gripe is that the beer prices are too high... 5$ plus beers should be reserved for the good stuff, not everything... I could go to a place like the winking lizard and have the same beer for $1 less. Regardless, I look forward to returning for some more pizza goodness.