Madison has some amazing culinary establishments, and I think The Old Fashioned is a bit overrated and doesn't belong on that list. There are much better eats in Madison! They do have a good beer list (but it's Madison-- that's a given), and they have an extensive menu, but their food is good (not great) and the wait is always long. If you want plenty of WI themed options and beer in an excellent location, The Old Fashioned will deliver. If you want the best food Madison has to offer, try somewhere else.