This place has some very very good pies, but is missing some pieces to be a 4 or 5 star places.
First, they don't have all of the pies listed on their site which was disappointing, but they said given 24 hours notice they can have any of them ready.
Second is the price, you are looking to pay at least $20 for most pies. Although they are "gourmet" I still feel this is a little too expensive.
They also have "dinner" pies, like lamb, or pork, or chicken pot pies. I had the Lamb and peas pie for lunch and it was pretty darn good. However a slice of that pie and a drink was over $13.