For being such a staple in the PITT- I wasn't blown away. Maybe it was my high expectations, or the size of the sandwich- but when it comes to making my mouth water- it just didn't create pools of drool like I anticipated. Turns out- we were eating with a 6 year old who ordered perogies, and I LOVED them (a lot more than my sandwich). Don't get me wrong- the sandwich was delicious, and the bf ate his and half of mine (that's a lot of food)- but it's not in my top 10 best sandwiches I've ever tasted- come on Pittsburgh! Don't let me down!
Also didn't dig the paper cups- made the water taste like... paper (that's not a good thing). However- friendly service and lively atmosphere made the experience a good one, and I definitely recommend trying their HUGE sandwiches if you're in the area.