TL;dr Same price as Hungry Howies, but better pizza just by a little
I always pass by this place because I take the light-rail. At some point I decided that I should probably check it out on Yelp, and if the reviews are positive I would make a quick visit here.
Thanks Yelp! If I didn't read some of the positive reviews, I probably would have never stopped by what sounds to be a sketch pizza place next to Food City. I think Big Jimmy's stole "mucho sabor" (lots of flavor) from Food City and put it all into their pizza. It was great, especially for $5.
More topppings than Hungry Howies, a healthy amount of greese, and a perfectly well-done crust make Big Jimmy's my new favorite $5 large pizza. I'd say that HHs and BJs are very close, except HHs crust is always a slight task to eat, where as BJs crust was very soft and more enjoyable to finish.
Of course, I might have to go to HHs just because my friends might not want pizza from a place that sounds so sketch. Its not sketch, its just amazing pizza.