I tried the walleye sandwich for the second time last night and it is a sandwich to be recognized. The only thing wrong with it is that it is, somehow, too big. But believe me when I say I will try to eat the whole thing every time.
My significant other ordered the house burger, which was delicious as well . We have been here in the past and tried specials, cheese plates and lazy susans. While nothing has been bad (I was impressed with their cheese platters especially) I have yet to have anything that is equally as delightful as the walleye sandwich.
I highly recommend the Old Fashioned for dinner or drinks. It offers a casual atmosphere and a great location on the square.