I have been to the original Carnegie's in NYC, so it's hard to compare this one to that, but it was okay at best.
Very expensive for what you get. The server asked if we wanted lettuce and tomato with our sandwich. I said, "Does it cost extra?" She responded, "Honey, EVERYTHING costs extra here!!" She wasn't joking.
A plain roast beef sandwich and fries cost us $25!!
Officially classify it as a tourist trap. Walk across the hall to BLT Burger and thank me later :)