This ice cream was okay. That's pretty much the only thing I could call it. That's not to say that it's bad but I was weirdly disappointed? For some reason I expected more.
This was my first foray into Graeter's. The inside of this place is huge and the staff is very friendly and helpful. I tried a few of the flavors and decided on a single scoop of the Black Cherry Chocolate Chip in a cup.
Here's the thing, the ice cream is fine. But I can't help but compare it to Mitchell's and I don't like it as much as much. It's not as rich and creamy as Mitchell's. It just seemed to be missing something.
The price is comparable to Mitchell's, not too bad. However, they have less choices than Mitchell's I believe and the flavors aren't unique. They had two seasonal flavors but they came across as generic.
Apart from ice cream you can buy chocolate there as well as jelly beans by the pound. Why? No idea but I fell into the jelly bean trap.
Overall, it's not a bad place but it's nothing to write home about. If you want ice cream and you're wondering through Crocker Place, stop by.