I am surprised I never wrote a review for Bake Sale!!
We have been coming here for years and their cupcakes are my mom's go to choice when celebrating someone's birthday in the family (everyone gets their own flavour plus you don't have a giant cake to inhale in the days following the celebration).
My fave items they sell are the peanut butter thumbprint cookies, gingerbread, and the peanut butter cupcakes (I LOVE peanut butter, can you tell)?
While some may say this place is pricey, I say it is well worth it - I have never had anything stale or off tasting, quality is consistent plus both the store and their products always look picture perfect. They also offer seasonal selections (like Easter themed cookies, etc).
Yay Bake Sale!!