Three stars basically because of price. The food was good, not anywhere near the best Italian I've had, but very, very overpriced. I have no problem paying for good food, but this just wasn't worth the money. For four of us - including one child's meal - it was $100. And that was with no appetizers. Guessing once you're featured on Guy Fieri's show, that justifies charging double the price of a normal meal???
Had the gnocchi, penne with veal sauce and lasagna. All were good, but they didn't wow us. Also, not sure why they are an Italian grocer, since they have only a handful of grocery items. But you can buy a loaf of their homemade bread for JUST $8.75. WTF? I can walk out of a bread-only bakery in NJ with two loaves of Italian bread and a dozen fresh baked rolls for $2!!!!