We came in for the first time ever, and were blown away by the food. We ordered 12 wings: 6 Buffalo, and Carolina Gold. We also had the Pepperoni Classic! Everything was awesome - service, food, even the unsweetened tea - which actually tasted like tea rather than colored water. Definitely will be back!
UPDATE: I am beyond broken-hearted to see that this place has been reported "closed!" That explains why my husband pulled into the parking lot last weekend and the place was dark, with chairs still on the tables. I hope this isn't really true - and was maybe an emergency closing or something; it is (was?) a great pizza place with very good food.