I still believe that is a 5-star restaurant, however, I had just an "okay" experience last I went. First off, we were seated in a high traffic area which was annoying. Secondly, the bread guy was not doing his job. Thirdly, I did not like the chicken livers that I ordered (I have never had them so I had no idea what to expect). We did get a delicious bottle of wine, so that helped me get through the so-so experience. The wait staff was also very friendly and were accommodating for our timeline (we had to get to the show after dinner). Next time I go back, I will make a reservation further in advance and I will try a different entree!