First off, expect there to be a crowd when you go here. I guess you can't keep good things a secret for long. Despite the crowds they have pretty fast service. They also will let you sample the flavors before you decide which probably isn't a bad idea because some of the flavor combinations are a little exotic compared to what you will find at your local baskin robbins. Personally I don't think you can go wrong with anything you pick here. They are a lot more expensive than some other ice cream places but you can tell that they use quality products so I don't mind the price difference at all. I am in love with salty carmel, dare i say addicted even perhaps. I don't live anywhere near Chagrin Falls so the days I don't feel like traveling out that way I can pick up a pint @ heinen's, Dave's (in OC) or Miles Market. Be careful this stuff is addictive!