I returned at Reggie's last night, and was sober this time with clarity of mind and tastebuds. So memory did serve me right. The poutine here is pretty good, both buzzed and sober!
A friend & I split the Regular Poutine w/ Chicken Gravy ($5) and the Pulled Pork Poutine w/ Goat Cheese & BBQ Sauce ($6.50). The regular is the better of the two in my book. I would definitely stick with that. My friends liked the pulled pork one better. I admit the pulled pork was good and not characteristically dry like how most pulled pork is. However, the pulled pork poutine pales in comparison to the original regular poutine. Goat cheese & BBQ sauce can't replace the fatty A magic of cheese curds & gravy. Reggie's uses chicken gravy, which is very good. This might possibly be my favorite poutine place.
I hear their Monte Cristo is good. If I'm willing to wean myself off of poutine, maybe I'll try it one day.