I was very happy with the selection and variety of cakes. The location is a bit far for me, but for a good cake, I am willing to make the drive. The baker was very accommodating, but the hours of operation are limited. I bought a cake for my fiancee's bday and i wanted the smallest one, which was 6x8, and it was only $29...personalized and all! When I went to pick it up, the cake was HUGE, 5 inches tall. I was expecting a 2-2.5 inch tall cake but I guess he tried to compensate for the lack of detail I asked for.
I really didn't notice anything shady about this business. If anything, I think he has limited/odd hours because he has limited, if any staff workers, so he needs the time to make the cakes himself. I was very happy with the product and will find any excuse possible to order another cake (just to try all of the amazing flavors).