I'm giving this place 3.5 stars mainly because the stuffed grape leaves were amazing. They came out and were surprisingly hot (temperature-wise)! I'd go back to have those grape leaves again. We also got a shawarma wrap and a falafel wrap and they were ok, but nothing special. I wish they had better sauces. The baklava was good, super sweet, but they give you a very small piece (good or bad thing depending on your perspective) so it's not overwhelming.
The service was not that great. We had to ask for lots of things, and there was this feeling that we were being rushed out, when we wanted to order dessert.
Ambiance was average. It was kind of fun finding this restaurant though. The underground location makes it feel more special.