I called this shop early this morning to make a last minute appointment for an alignment. They got me in immediately and were incredibly polite and helpful. They also informed me that my oil cap was missing and offered to replace it there, or show me where the closest autozone was so I could buy the part myself. I decided to go the cheaper route and buy it myself. They actually called autozone and had the right cap set aside. At no time did I feel they were taking advantage of me, and even though they could've tried to sell me on other unnecessary services (it's an old car), they never even went there. That's a nice change as compared to Midas or other chains.
So far the car drives well. I don't expect to be disappointed, but I'll definitely update this review if something goes wrong. But so far, this is my new go-to car shop.