Cibo was good, but I'll admit nothing was really outstanding. We went as a group of 5 and shared five appetizers (scodellina), as well as 2 pastas plus a pizza. The prices were comparable to other places, but the only thing that REALLY blew my taste buds was the eggplant dip. I'm not a pasta person but they weren't really anything special in my opinion, and I'd had better pizza the night before at Beer Revolution.
The decor is pretty cool, though.
One side remark: Their servers wear casual dress (i.e. no dress code) which turns me off a little - I'd like to be able to tell the servers apart from the patrons at a glance.
All in all, I'd go back if a friend organized a group of people to go or really wanted to visit, but it wouldn't be top of my list of places to consider going back to.