I've been here twice and absolutely loved it both times.
I always have a super hard time deciding what to get because everything looks so good, and to make it harder everything I've actually tried has been amazing.
Items I've had include:
-Cheese Curds (not quite on par with the Old Fashioned's but very close)
-Mac 'n Cheese w/pulled pork
-Pub Burger
-Cheesecake
-The Marquez Collins cocktail (or the Marques Colston as my friends and I enjoy calling it)
-Really Magic Coffee cocktail
Considering the location and menu the prices are very reasonable (though you can ring up the bill pretty fast with those cocktails).
On top of all that the atmosphere is awesome, especially at night when you can look over Capitol Square. And while the wait is usually a bit long (30-45 minutes) you can usually find a place at the bar and hang out there in the mean time. Service is good too, everyone seems really friendly and helpful in explaining the menu and checking on you throughout the meal.
In sum, it's a great place to go to dinner with friends. Great view, great food, tolerably priced, and unlike its neighbor/partner L'etoile, you can actually feel relaxed while you're there and not feel self conscious about belting out in laughter.