The chocolate chip cookies are phenomenal - definitely try if you like butter and chocolate!
As for the cupcakes, there are some that are pure win and others that are a flop.
If you like exotic, you might like the honey and lavender cupcake but for me, it just tastes like lavender perfume. I've heard the red velvet is good if you like that kind.
The chocolate and vanilla flavors are excellent when they're fresh. Unfortunately, I have gotten dry or stale cupcakes from here on occasion and they're just too pricey for that.
It's a nice shop for sitting and enjoying your treats and drinks. They also sell candies and some very expensive but tasty ice cream (Jeni's Ice Cream from Ohio).