A group of 4 of us came here on a Friday night. Everywhere on East 4th was busy. We weren't expecting to find a table or seat at the bar, but to our surprise they had open tables and promptly sat us at one. Our server took 15 minutes to greet us with menus, then another 10 to come back and take our order. Our drinks took another 15 minutes. We really appreciate a great cocktail and are patient and understanding that they can take some time to make, especially when made correctly, but we all got old fashions. When they delivered our drinks, they tasted very watered down like they had been sitting at the service bar for a while. Mine had no orange, cherry, or bitters taste to it- it simply tasted like watered down bourbon over ice :( the atmosphere is really nice, and the staff was friendly. I like how they deliver the check in a cigar box. Our old fashions were $15 a piece and worth $5 I'd say. Definitely disappointed in our drinks and the time it took but it's a nice intimate underground speakeasy style place.