Pros:
-Very clean
-Awesomely comfortable beds with super fluffy pillows
-Quiet (and we were there on a busy weekend with a home football game)
-Starbucks in the lobby and in the hotel rooms
-Was able to get a room on Priceline for $60 the day before we arrived
-Free parking
-Foursquare promotion = free breakfast buffet in the restaurant
-Friendly, helpful staff
-Not right downtown but easily a 5-10 min drive from the Capitol
Cons:
-Like another reviewer said, the showerhead is very low - not great for tall guests
-Some rooms face railroad tracks; we didn't hear any trains but not sure if this is disruptive at other times
Overall, a great place. It seems like it's been recently updated and well-maintained. I'd recommend it to anyone traveling through Madison.