Best burger in Madison hands down! I always get the Melting Pot. There's a reason it is their most sold burger. Oh, and it is topped with bacon, so there's that. The burgers are big. Call me a wimp, but I always ask for a knife so I can cut mine in half.
If you get fries, get a basket to share amongst yourselves. Unfortunately the burgers do not come with fries. There is malt vinegar on the table to make your fries English style...always a plus
Warning: Do not come here on a night that there is a sporting event at the Kohl Center. Or, if you do, be prepared to wait.