I let non-Yelping friends select where to eat lunch and we ended up at Xtreme Sushi. It was the closest place to their house for sushi, and we were famished, so I just went with it. As they say, hindsite is 20/20...
One of the 'pros' to Xtreme Sushi I had heard from friends was the price. And they were right, AYCE is cheaper then most places... We missed lunch but dinner was only $24 each. However they made up for the cheap AYCE by charging $3 for iced tea.
We started out with an order of edamame and the Xtreme Orgasm salad. The edamame took far too long to come out. The salad was boring. Big slabs of tuna on some mixed greens with just a drizzle of sauce. I realized what kind of establishment I was in when the waitress informed me that ACYE means I am expected to eat all of the salad... I order salads at various AYCE sushi places around town and have never, EVER had the waitress give me a hard time about not eating all of the lettuce.
On to the sushi. We ordered multiple rolls and nigiri... We specifically requested 3 orders of seared tuna nigiri and 3 of garlic nigiri, and recieved 4 of each. Normally this would not be an issue, normally we would be fighting over who got the extra order... but the fish quality at Xtreme was crap. Apparently 'seared' means 'dry and chewy with blackened rice'.
The only item we ordered that I wasn't completely disappointed with was the Caterpiller roll. Which was the only item we ordered that was completely cooked. In the end we were charged for a half roll because we didn't finish all of the food. It was only $4, not worth arguing about nor was it worth punishing our tastebuds over!
I'd rather pay a few dollars more for better tasting sushi then to ever step foot in Xtreme again.