We were here to see Arlo Guthrie in the upstairs room. Our previous visit had been downstairs and I think we agree that the acoustics are better upstairs. We didn't eat, just had drinks. Although service was great, the drinks were small for the price.
The tables are very close together so if you are claustrophobic this may not be the place for you. I would suggest ordering tickets as early as possible and try to sit up front because otherwise people block your view (I am short so this is always a problem).
I wish I could see concerts and not have the people around me ruin the event. This is not a problem for the Supper Club, just a comment to Yelp readers. I paid $75 to hear Arlo sing, not people around me. This is not a karaoke bar. Why did YOU pay $75 if all you were going to do is talk to your friend the ENTIRE concert. This is not the only venue I have encountered this issue. Why can't people just enjoy the music?