Really overrated. I hadn't been here in two years and went for lunch today -- now I remember why I didn't bother. They are really stingy with toppings. I think I could count on one hand the number of tiny black beans the woman behind the counter put on my burrito. The guacamole is an unappealing shade of grey/green and looks too smooth and uniform in texture; that said, I couldn't really taste it as I was barely given any. The rice is bland and dry. The red salsa looks and tastes like something from an Old El Paso container. Only the halibut, which seemed quite fresh, and the somewhat spicy hot sauce saved this. Honestly, would rather go to Chipotle - for the same price, at least they really stuff the burrito and the ingredients aren't any less fresh.
Toronto's burrito/Mexican scene is pathetic, but I'm not surprised that all the 905ers who crowd this place on weekends don't know any better.