I've eaten in a few times and had very mixed experiences. On a weeknight we have had great food and great service and the same on a weekend. However we have also had the polar opposite. At it's best we were seated quickly and had an attentive and happy server, but we had two different experiences where despite calling ahead, our name was missed on the list, the host/manager/server were rude and neglectful and the food was lukewarm and lacking flavor.
I wish I could agree with the number of positive reviews but every time I have gone back expecting a different experience, the difference has been marginal.
I would recommend taking the 15 minute drive downtown to any number of great breakfast or brunch options. Your food and experience with be much more consistent and unique to Madison.