Tony's is my neighborhood pick for good pizza and Italian food. It's even served with a (small) amount of NY attitude to let you know you're getting the real deal. Seriously though, my BF and I have ALWAYS had fantastic, fast service any time we've eaten in or picked up.
We usually go for the classic pepperoni (delicious) but have also enjoyed the "Taste of Italy Special" and the spinach pizza. BF also often orders the subs, calzones and wings and I've tried a few of the pasta dishes and we have yet to be disappointed.
Give them a try! You won't regret it. We're so glad they came to the neighborhood!