I don't have a sweet tooth, I have 28 of them. That being said, my husband and I stopped by on a Tuesday afternoon, and were sorely disappointed in the sparse selection-maybe 4 or 5 varieties at best. I had the "Tuxedo" (chocolate cake with vanilla frosting), while my husband tried the Rich and Famous (chocolate on chocolate). We both found the cake to be average. The vanilla frosting was plentiful and satisfyingly sweet. The chocolate frosting was another disappointment, lacking that "oh my god" factor you hope for in a chocolate dessert.
Even more disappointing we would soon find out is the customer service. My husband attempted to special order a cupcake creation and was rudely told "we don't do that." He tried to explain all he wanted was a "cake" assembled from cupcakes arranged together and frosted as a whole. Their response was the same. Interesting since their website indicates they "welcome" special orders.
If your only requirement in a cupcake is gobs of frosting with a price tag to match, make the trip. Otherwise, start baking.