My wife and I went there for the first time on Thursday. Its our anniversary this weekend but we have to travel so had an early anniversary dinner. Didnt know where we were going till we started naming off places to go in the car. We decided to give Spoon a try and were very happy. Ambiance was nice, service was very good. We didn't have a reservation, but we were able to get a table before the rush.
I had the foie gras appetizer and it was dynamite. I have had very few that I thought were better and it was presented in a range of forms. Well worth the cost for sure! My wife decided not to get an appetizer, but loved the bread. For dinner she had the beef two ways. A short rib over smashed potato with some gorgonzola I think and a sliced ribeye with some fresh veg and salad. I had the pappardelle with rabbit ragu. Both were really good. I liked mine better than hers but that was what hit the spot for me that night.
Service was very attentive, but not overly so. Desert (which I am not much of a sweet eater) was a chocolate bark kind of thing. I tasted it and it was good. My wife loved it.
Overall, I was more impressed than I thought I would be and the prices are quite reasonable I think for the level of food.