I should be dumbfounded by the rave reviews of this place given the quality of pizza, but there are other very average pizza places in Gilbert that have also garnered 4.5 star ratings.
I suggested Brooklyn V's last Friday when I was watching a movie with my parents. No one felt like driving so our usual go to, Grimaldi's, wasn't going to happen. I checked on Yelp and saw that I could get delivery from a place that I bookmarked over a year ago. Perfect timing!
Unfortunately, the pizza was a big let down. We got the margherita ($29 with tip and tax), and it was so unmemorable. The crust was really bad. Usually, I love crust, but with this one, I was wishing my dogs were around so I give them their "pizza bones." I didn't like the grape tomatoes either. Cheese and sauce were fine. Again, just very average. My dad crisped up my 2nd piece in a frying pan, and that seemed to help.
Lesson learned. Don't be lazy. Drive to Grimaldi's.