Recently after finishing a dinner nearby restaurant, we wanted to partake in some more of Ohio's ice cream (I am a firm believer that Ohio has the best ice cream in the US) and came across this place. I am a fan of custard, and sometimes even prefer it to ice cream - in terms of flavor and texture.
We'd heard about this place from some locals and decided to check this out. We debated between the here and somewhere more chain, but of course decided to go with the local option. I had the peanut butter and it was delicious - really creamy and not too overwhelming on the peanut butter flavor. It was a good price for the serving and the service was friendly.
I wish this place could have gotten five stars, but the sprinkling of sprinkles hurt that - personally I think sprinkles should be rolled onto the ice cream, covering it almost fully. Additionally I was told there was no swirl or half/half on one scoop - now I get this isn't served the same way, but I also can't believe I'm the first customer to ask for that or understand why you couldn't do half a scoop and half, or some other innovative solution to allow for two flavors in a small.