My sister and I both agree that Lobster Me was just ok, and was pretty pricey. Even though we had gotten there shortly after 10, we received food that seemed like it had been sitting out (i.e. it wasn't piping hot). I chose the lobster roll, which had a good amount of lobster but tasted just ok. My sister had the lobster mac and cheese- and she's had better. She said that the lobster was sprinkled on top instead of baked together, so the flavors didn't meld together.
We also shared a clam chowder, which was a bit liquid-y and slightly sour. Not a huge fan.
Overall, just 3/5.