I'm giving Jimmy's three stars because the young lady that took care of us last night was very good (customer service). But, don't go for the salmon salad or the linguine with white sauce. My wife said the clams were pretty rubbery and the salmon salad, while good, was nothing that I would reorder (overpriced and nothing spectacular). The place seems to do a booming business with locals. Maybe the pizza or other things on the menu are what draw folks in. Nice atmosphere and good service but there is better Italian food to be found in Gilbert.
Fortunately, we were with friends so the food quality was only secondary to the quality of the evening.