I consider this a 5 because I go there at least once per month. Every friend and their moms want to go there when they visit. If you go there as much as I do, you can get a 10%+ discount by joining their free membership. (I hope it's still available cause I joined ages ago)
FOOD:
Let's just say I'll eat anything produced from this place. Everything is good and sometimes they have specials posted on the walls. You may want to bring binoculars to read them or walk around the tables to read it.
You can plan a reservation 2 hrs ahead - that's what I do because the wait may be long on busy nights.