I thoroughly enjoyed my experience at Toasted! The husband and I came on a day when they sampled their cheese curds....they were salty in the best possible way...yum. We ordered the pretzels with cheese, which were tasty, maybe not the most exciting thing in the world, but good. We split their SoCal grilled cheese and I swear their habanero relish was sooooo gooood. Their fries were thin and tasty. We also split their banana bread dessert, which was ridic tasty. Definitely recommend this item! The prices aren't cheap, but they aren't exorbitant either.
The only weird part about Toasted is that they don't have too many non meat options (doesn't bother me too much, but I can see where others may be irked) and if you remove the meat from their grilled cheese options, they would be vastly overpriced.
Regardless, I would return.