Ten penny is great for dinner. I went with family on a Saturday night and things were a little loud, especially by the bar, but the staff courteously sat us towards the back away from the bulk of the noise.
The ceasar salad was excellent in the maple candied ham on the side of the salad at a nice zing at the end of the salad.
The family member I was with loved her pasta Primavera with veggies and said that she would order it again if you were to come back to TenPenny. I had the stuffed on this chicken for my main course, and it was good but I feel like, in retrospect, the whipped potatoes and the lemon flavor drowned out both the asparagus and the chicken and, it really seemed like the chicken was a side dish to the whipped potatoes. It's worth mentioning that the menu for the Amish chicken noted that there was an artichoke heart in the dish. I couldn't taste it at all unless it was in the whipped potato stuff.
The staff at tenpenny was all very courteous and very nice, but my biggest issue is that almost as soon as I was done with my salad, my main course and my family member's main course were brought out. The restaurant was fairly busy but not to the point where our main course should've been brought out that quickly.
Overall, I strongly recommend TenPenny, and will definitely go back in the future. Four out of five stars.