This place is fabulous. I was taken here for my birthday last February, and everything about it was 5-star quality. The atmosphere is cozy and intimate - there was a guy playing acoustic guitar quietly which was a nice touch.
We started with a bottle of Reisling which arrive chilled and in a bucket on ice... then tried the goat cheese appetizer witih mangoes... YUM. I had stuffed peppers for my entree and they were amazing... tons of veggies, rice, and slivered almonds ensconced in yellow peppers, topped with melted parmesan.
Finally, the waitress brought me a creme brulee for dessert with a candle in it - on the house! I hate drawing attention at restaurants, but free dessert? I'll take it!
Also, very reasonable prices for top-quality French cuisine... I'd be back if I were still in Madison for sure.