Just went here for lunch. I really wanted to try this place for dinner, but I was in the area (@ Steven Paul for a haircut), was hungry, and had a gift cert from Local Dines ( http://bit.ly/dfR4eQ ).
There are a few paninis and pizzas on the menu for lunch. They have about 5 or 6 paninis on the menu and they all sounded pretty good. The chef said the grilled cheese was his fav so I had to go with that. It wasn't the best grilled cheese I've ever had but it was pretty darn good. The bread was amazing and the roasted red pepper stuff was a unique touch. The chips that came with were pretty standard. The paninis are about 8 bucks a pop so I guess that is pretty standard for the area and not totally outrageous.
I didn't like, however, that they had no salads on the menu and were out of the 'soup of the day'.
For something sweet my wife and I split the pudding. It was sweet, chocolaty, thick and rich. Although it was very small, it was more than enough for 2 people to take a few spoon-fulls so it was perfect.
The chef/cashier was extremely friendly and helpful. I definitely want to come back to try their dinner creations after looking at the Yelp reviews.