We spent Valentine's Day 2015 here and it was a great experience. Food was timed perfectly, friendly wait staff, chef visited each table, manager brought a rose to each lady dining....the food was amazing except for the seafood in the diavolo was overcooked. Points for using Ohio City pasta though. The sauces were perfection from the chili lime sauce on the calamari appetizer, the homemade ceaser on the salad, the orange something that accompanied the macadamia crusted grouper to the raspberry on the chocolate dessert we shared.
There are two dining options, downstairs in the pub and upstairs fine dining with two different menus. If you sit in the pub you can order off either menu. If we find ourselves in Medina again I would go back to try a burger at the pub.