We tried Cathy's Creamery today after hearing so much buzz and seeing all the delicious pictures.
They did not disappoint! The store is nestled downtown with ample street parking near by. The shop itself has a few small tables, but we chose to eat our ice cream sandwiches outside.
The homemade cookies are very generous portions and the ice cream they put on top, even more generous! They let you totally customize your ice cream sandwich. You pick the cookies you want to use (2 different if you'd like), the ice cream, and what they coat the sides in. All that for $5!
I picked chocolate chip cookies, with banana fosters ice cream, and the Pecans to coat the sides. It was phenomenal!
If I have any recommendations, grab lots of napkins, a bowl, and a spoon. With the heat and the big portion, it was difficult to eat. But that's a good problem in my book. These are sizable enough to share as well.