I was really looking forward to trying this new spot, but I was really disappointed with the cookies.
I like to start with the good. The shop was clean and the employee that helped us was quick to greet us and box up the cookies. Pricing is very reasonable, for nine mini cookies it was only around $6. The case was full and well stocked with about a dozen flavors of mini cookies and plenty of full size cookie options too.
Based on the name of the shop I was expecting a sugar cookie. Sugar cookies are usually buttery with a slight crisp on the outside and a slightly soft inside. These "cookies" were similar in texture to a cake and were oddly spongey with little flavor in the cookie part. The flavor of the frosting was good, but the texture was so off-putting that I couldn't eat them. At first they reminded me of the Lofthouse sugar cookies from the grocery store, but I don't think they were even that good.