I had my car repaired there a year ago. I had to bring it back three times. Then Gerber actually paid another shop to repair my car properly. That was after I filed complaints to the BBB and with Geico. By the way. The on site Geico rep at the shop does not care how the repairs are done. He probably gets a kickback from the shop.
They could not align my rear bumper properly. They could not install the spoiler flush on the trunk. They painted the deck lid (trunk) and then sat it on the floor while it was drying. The paint was chipped all around the edges. The manager actually told me that everyone else would take the car the way it was. He thought I was nit picking.
The reason I am writing this review a year latter is because I was looking at my drivers side quarter panel yesterday with the a guy from another body shop, he showed me what a poor paint job they did at Gerber when they blended the paint together. You can't really notice it unless someone points it out to you, but that is not the point. It was not blended properly and it looks terrible. The warranty from them doesn't matter, because I would never let them touch my car again. Do not go here.