I was back in town for a week and I heard about this place having real NYC style pizza. I expected it to be typical mediocre pizza but it was really really good.
I can't compare it to pizza you might find in New York but compared to pizza you find around here, it is excellent. The crust is thin, the pizza is gigantic and it is basic and memorable. We got an 18 inch cheese and an 18 inch pepperoni and the cheese was better. This kind of pizza doesn't support mountains of toppings and the pepperoni pizza seemed overpowered. The cheese pizza was amazing and a reasonable person could eat much more pizza than usual since the crust is so thin. Get more than you think you'll want.
The people running the place are really nice and seem thankful that you're giving them a try. They have a chipotle knockoff tacqueria there too but I can't say if it is good. Based on their efforts with the pizza, I'd give it a try.
Another plus; an 18 inch cheese pizza costs ten bucks. In Chicago, they'd want at least twenty and it wouldn't be this good. If you're sick of boring mediocre pizza, try this place.