I see that some of the other Bonanno's are getting poor reviews - those might just be the take-out pizza slices, because there is nothing negative to say about this place.
We sat on the restaurant side and had a wonderful experience - extremely friendly and attentive staff, nice atmosphere and pleasing music (Sinatra and the like).
The garlic bread is fab and my boyfriend and I split a pizza and a salad - both huge, and both delicious.