My husband loves this place... it's growing on me. We order cheese, nothing special and toss some crushed red pepper flakes, parmesan cheese and crushed oregano all over it. What really makes the pie... ranch dressing. It's probably a sin to dip your pizza into ranch, but hands-down, Verrazano's has the best ranch dressing I've ever experienced. Sadly, I will claim to be a ranch connoisseur, you could even say I'm a ranch snob. I would eat this ranch dressing off an old flip-flop.
I haven't eaten much else there yet but I will totally update after I do. It's around the corner from me and it's the hubby's favorite so I know I'll be eating here again soon.