After several attempts to like Good Fellas - I have now officially given up. The prices are outrageous for the quality not to mention the (lack of) service.
I ordered a take out pizza tonight. Quoted 15-20 minutes, I arrived in 15 and was handed a cold pizza that I have now had to heat up in my own oven. I asked for a light sprinkling of parmesan cheese on top, and was charged an additional $5.00!!! I understand you cannot give away free food/toppings, but this is a common request to finish the Margherita pizza, which itself was $15.00. It did not warrant that extreme of a cost. It's a tacky way to put off a customer that otherwise loves to dine out and is willing to pay for quality and service.
I will not spend any more of my money here. What a disappointment for the neighborhood.